A Single Fax Changed Everything for This Hospital

In 2011, a hospital employee in Minnesota faxed a patient's psychiatric records to an employer instead of an insurance company. One wrong number. That mistake triggered a complaint, an OCR investigation, and months of corrective action. The question at the center of it all was deceptively simple: who was this organization allowed to disclose PHI to?

If you work in healthcare — or for any covered entity or business associate — understanding exactly who you can and cannot send PHI to is not optional. It's the foundation of everything HIPAA was built to protect. And in my experience, it's the area where the most expensive mistakes happen.

This post breaks down every category of permitted and required disclosure so your workforce knows the boundaries before they hit "send."

What Does "PHI To" Actually Mean Under HIPAA?

PHI stands for protected health information — any individually identifiable health data that a covered entity creates, receives, maintains, or transmits. When we talk about disclosing PHI to someone, we're talking about releasing, transferring, providing access to, or otherwise making that information available to another person or entity.

The HIPAA Privacy Rule at 45 CFR Part 164, Subpart E sets the ground rules. It dictates when you can send PHI to a third party, when you must send it, and when doing so will land your organization in serious trouble.

The Two Disclosures HIPAA Requires — No Exceptions

Most people focus on permitted disclosures. But HIPAA actually requires covered entities to disclose PHI to two specific recipients.

1. The Individual (or Their Personal Representative)

When a patient requests access to their own medical records, you must provide them. The 2024 OCR guidance reaffirmed this with teeth. In fact, HHS settled with Cignet Health of Prince George's County for $4.3 million back in 2011 — largely because the organization refused to give 41 patients access to their own records. That remains one of the largest HIPAA penalties ever tied directly to a right-of-access violation.

2. HHS During a Compliance Investigation or Review

When the Office for Civil Rights comes knocking, you hand over what they ask for. Obstructing an OCR investigation by withholding PHI is a separate violation that escalates penalties fast.

The 12 Permitted Disclosures: Who You Can Send PHI To

Beyond those two required disclosures, the Privacy Rule permits — but does not require — covered entities to disclose PHI to specific parties under specific conditions. Here's where your team needs crystal clarity.

Treatment, Payment, and Healthcare Operations (TPO)

This is the workhorse category. You can disclose PHI to other providers for treatment, to insurers for payment, and internally for quality assurance, auditing, and training. No patient authorization needed. But the minimum necessary standard still applies to payment and operations — you share only what's needed, nothing more.

With the Individual's Written Authorization

Outside of TPO and the other permitted categories, you need a signed authorization before sending PHI to anyone. Marketing communications, sale of PHI, and most disclosures to employers all fall here. The authorization must be specific, time-limited, and revocable.

Public Health Activities

Covered entities may disclose PHI to public health authorities for disease surveillance, reporting vital events, tracking FDA-regulated products, and workplace medical surveillance.

Victims of Abuse, Neglect, or Domestic Violence

You can report PHI to government authorities authorized to receive abuse or neglect reports. State law often makes this mandatory, and HIPAA steps aside to allow it.

Health Oversight Activities

PHI can go to agencies conducting audits, investigations, inspections, and licensure actions — think state health departments, CMS, and OIG.

Judicial and Administrative Proceedings

Courts and administrative tribunals can receive PHI if there's a valid order, subpoena, or discovery request — with appropriate safeguards in place.

Law Enforcement

Six specific sub-categories allow disclosures to law enforcement: court orders, grand jury subpoenas, administrative requests, identifying or locating suspects, reports about crime victims, and reporting deaths that may result from criminal conduct.

Decedents

Coroners, medical examiners, and funeral directors can receive PHI to carry out their duties. Organ procurement organizations are included here as well.

Research

PHI can be disclosed for research purposes when an Institutional Review Board or Privacy Board has waived the authorization requirement, or when researchers use only de-identified data or a limited data set with a data use agreement.

Serious Threat to Health or Safety

If someone faces an imminent threat, you can disclose PHI to those who can reasonably prevent or lessen the danger — including law enforcement, family members, or the target of the threat.

Specialized Government Functions

Military and veterans' activities, national security and intelligence, protective services for the President, and correctional institutions all have carved-out exceptions.

Workers' Compensation

PHI may be disclosed as authorized by and to the extent necessary to comply with workers' compensation laws.

The Minimum Necessary Rule: The Guardrail Everyone Forgets

Even when a disclosure is permitted, you can't dump an entire medical chart on someone's desk. The minimum necessary standard requires you to limit PHI to the smallest amount needed to accomplish the purpose of the disclosure.

I've seen organizations fail here more than anywhere else. A billing department sends a full record to an insurer when only a procedure code and diagnosis were needed. A nurse faxes ten pages to a specialist who asked for one lab result. These aren't hypotheticals — they're the patterns OCR investigators look for.

The only exception: disclosures for treatment purposes between providers. That's the one scenario where minimum necessary doesn't apply.

What Happens When You Send PHI to the Wrong Person?

Sending PHI to an unauthorized recipient is a breach under the HIPAA Breach Notification Rule. That triggers a cascade: you must conduct a risk assessment, potentially notify the affected individuals, notify HHS, and in cases affecting 500 or more people, notify the media.

In 2018, Anthem, Inc. paid $16 million to settle HIPAA violations after a massive breach exposed ePHI of nearly 79 million individuals. While that case involved a cyberattack, OCR's investigation also examined Anthem's internal access controls — specifically, who had access to PHI and whether the organization had properly restricted who ePHI was available to.

At the other end of the scale, the OCR Right of Access enforcement initiative has produced over 45 settlements, many under $100,000, all because a covered entity sent PHI to the wrong party — or refused to send it to the right one.

How to Train Your Workforce on PHI Disclosures

Policies on paper mean nothing if your front desk staff, billing team, and clinicians don't understand them. Here's what I recommend based on two decades of watching organizations succeed and fail.

Make Disclosure Rules Part of Onboarding — Not an Afterthought

Every new hire should complete HIPAA workforce training before they touch a patient record. Not thirty days in. Not "when we get around to it." Day one.

Your team doesn't need to memorize 45 CFR section numbers. They need to know: "Can I tell this caller whether their mother is a patient here?" "Can I email a discharge summary to this case manager?" Scenario-based training sticks. Abstract policy lectures don't.

Refresh Annually — At Minimum

HIPAA requires periodic training, and I've never seen an organization get in trouble for training too often. Explore the full HIPAA training catalog to find role-specific courses that go beyond generic overviews.

Quick Reference: Who Can You Disclose PHI To?

  • Required: The patient (upon request) and HHS (during investigations).
  • Permitted without authorization: Other providers for treatment, payers for payment, public health authorities, law enforcement (under specific conditions), researchers (with IRB waiver), courts (with valid orders), and several other categories outlined in the Privacy Rule.
  • Requires written authorization: Employers (for non-treatment purposes), marketers, any sale of PHI, and any purpose not covered by the permitted categories.
  • Always applies: The minimum necessary standard (except for treatment disclosures between providers).

The Bottom Line: Know Before You Disclose

Every time someone in your organization sends PHI to another party, they're making a compliance decision — whether they realize it or not. The question "who can I send PHI to?" should be as automatic as hand-washing is for clinicians.

Get the training right. Build verification steps into your workflows. And when you're not sure, stop and check before you disclose. The HHS guidance on permitted uses and disclosures is your authoritative reference — bookmark it.

Because the cost of guessing wrong isn't a slap on the wrist. It's a breach investigation, a corrective action plan, and a settlement amount with a lot of zeros.